rules vs discretion the wrong choice could open the floodgates

30 0 obj << /Linearized 1 /O 32 /H [ 1380 296 ] /L 49906 /E 37500 /N 2 /T 49188 >> endobj xref 30 48 0000000016 00000 n 0000001307 00000 n 0000001676 00000 n 0000001883 00000 n 0000002131 00000 n 0000002346 00000 n 0000003135 00000 n 0000003315 00000 n 0000003336 00000 n 0000004049 00000 n 0000004070 00000 n 0000004792 00000 n 0000005340 00000 n 0000005566 00000 n 0000005587 00000 n 0000006328 00000 n 0000006875 00000 n 0000007098 00000 n 0000007119 00000 n 0000007885 00000 n 0000007906 00000 n 0000008631 00000 n 0000008953 00000 n 0000009166 00000 n 0000009379 00000 n 0000009564 00000 n 0000009585 00000 n 0000010359 00000 n 0000010577 00000 n 0000011121 00000 n 0000012228 00000 n 0000012521 00000 n 0000013059 00000 n 0000013427 00000 n 0000013594 00000 n 0000014516 00000 n 0000014665 00000 n 0000014953 00000 n 0000015496 00000 n 0000015849 00000 n 0000015870 00000 n 0000016627 00000 n 0000016648 00000 n 0000017402 00000 n 0000017908 00000 n 0000037271 00000 n 0000001380 00000 n 0000001655 00000 n trailer << /Size 78 /Info 28 0 R /Root 31 0 R /Prev 49178 /ID[<22db6f35b0770c753ea1e15051a25132><8d2178eab2f5b044bd73e4333c40d219>] >> startxref 0 %%EOF 31 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 27 0 R /Metadata 29 0 R >> endobj 76 0 obj << /S 98 /Filter /FlateDecode /Length 77 0 R >> stream Did it open opportunities in the community for someone to offer care on that day? Fear Of Opening The Floodgates Law General Essay. See Hall, King, Meyer and Vaughan (2002) for more details. Today, before flooding has occurred, they can try to discourage floodplain construction by forswearing disaster relief. Suppose, for example, a river that seldom floods rises above its banks and sweeps away homes. See 'break the seal.' U+YA�pM�(����A� �i�7������p�I��Ҡ��_Q���D�C��9�Y���@�UQ�eo���'0�l���� ��l���MB��Ԩ$��:������Kȷܪ���c�$��l �k�>v�yd`4Nؚ�RD�kݭ���BvY���[��k�\���8���V9���u�挼�yq��N���h�q�[�a�M��6HÝ�A�)��@l聻q��R ء�EylW`�.��u3��+f�7��]�2qu*�n5�f:���H�#�E��c*� ��rAg��yFI�{��71�Eܵ��(��ǖf����LLɉl��O�앩h���s����p�hT��%kV���J���5�I!c�]�:ܸf�����9��S�&�e����ox�O� �8}l endstream endobj 39 0 obj 644 endobj 40 0 obj << /Filter /FlateDecode /Length 39 0 R >> stream The floodgates principle, or the floodgates argument, is a legal principle which is sometimes applied by judges to restrict or limit the right to make claims for damages because of a concern that permitting a claimant to recover in such situations might open the metaphorical "floodgates" to large numbers of claims and lawsuits. A floodgates argument is a type of argument based on policy considerations or "the bigger picture" rather than the just result in an individual case. H��T�n�0����"bDɲ���@���Cu3r`(�a#��H��g�E��K=9�Q� �3��34�Cp��;�� bȷ�v[��mJ� �2���ep����X��_i�A� 473-91. We believe the Federal Reserve most effectively serves the public by building a more diverse and inclusive economy. To discourage such building, they announce that anyone suffering flood damage is on his own—no disaster relief will be forthcoming. 10-11 Jason J. Buol and Mark D. Vaughan Monetary policy: the whole country gets the same treatment, but results vary pp. ... the-wrong-choice-could-open-the-floodgates . The public will anticipate this possibility; so, in the end, inflation will be higher but unemployment will be no lower. In a rules framework, policy responses must follow a pre-specified plan. Friedman did concede, however, that constraints on policy were more important than the numerical target range; so, this policy prescription is often characterized as a, They noted that central banks with discretion have an incentive to renege on commitments to price stability. A Program for Monetary Stability. [, See Friedman (1960). Kydland, Finn E. and Prescott, Edward C. “Rules Rather than Discretion: The Inconsistency of Optimal Plans.” Journal of Political Economy, Vol. This result offers the worst of both worlds—homes are destroyed by floodwater, and victims who ignored warnings are indemnified with taxpayer funds. If given absolute discretion, supervisors might announce an informal policy of closing banks whenever capital-to-asset ratios fall below, say, 5 percent. Operation & Maintenance. No precise monetary rules were applied by monetary authorities except the "gold standard" and the exchange rate stability [15]. They remain open for car, train and boat traffic but are closed during a storm event. The Supreme Court has increasingly considered a particular kind of argument: that it should avoid reaching decisions that would “open the floodgates of litigation.” Despite its frequent invocation, there has been little scholarly exploration of what a floodgates argument truly means, and even less discussion of its normative basis. As a result, the apprehension that the floodgates may be open too wide, needs to be allayed by recognizing that many will pass the primary level for the purpose of establishing the required degree of injury. 1-30. … Blinder, Alan S. Central Banking in Theory and Practice. The plan can be non-activist in nature—the rule may force policy-makers to pursue the same course of action in all circumstances. Learn more. Understanding how monetary policy works and how it can be affected, by either rules or discretion, is crucial and all possibilities must be taken into account to establish the most effective outcome for our economy. If policy-makers are relatively independent from the political process, then they can resist pressure from undeserving flood victims —those who ignored warnings—to renege on threats of no relief. In the short run, however, compassion dictates bailing out victims—even those who failed to heed warnings. National and District Overview: Recovery Has a Case of the Slows, President's Message: The Fed Lends a Helping Hand—and Sometimes a Push, Central Banker: News from the St. Louis Fed, In Plain English: Making Sense of the Federal Reserve, Economics and Personal Finance Glossary and Flashcards, Materials and Videos from Featured Events, Center for Household Financial Stability HOME, Manuals, Regulations, Laws & Other Guidance, In Plain English - Making Sense of the Federal Reserve, They also used a floodplain example. Discretion: The Wrong Choice Could Open the Floodgates. Rules vs. discretion: the wrong choice could open the floodgates pp. Kydland and Prescott were not the first to comment on the value of policy rules. Definition of open the floodgates in the Idioms Dictionary. 1. 10 Apr. Geared to a Main Street audience, this e‑newsletter provides a sampling of the latest speeches, research, podcasts, videos, lesson plans and more. Read ^Sound Monetary Policy _ … A trigger mechanism forcing supervisors to act whenever capital ratios dipped below 5 percent would spur bankers to maintain high ratios. ... maintaining the debt ceiling could have resulted in more sustainable budgeting choices and programs in the future. Friedman believed that an independent central bank (“wide discretion to independent experts” (p.239)) is not the answer. Kydland and Prescott’s emphasis on the importance of the framework—and the value of credible rules—has profoundly influenced the way other economists think about policy. A time-inconsistent policy may make the public happy in the short run but will ultimately fail to produce the long-run policy goal. Improvement Act of 1991 (FDICIA), bank supervisors had almost complete discretion over bank closings. Davis, Steven and Haltiwanger, John. Read ^The Effects of the Great Recession on Central Bank Doctrine and Practice” by Ben Bernanke 4. ... Rules vs. open the floodgates meaning: 1. Proponents of discretionary policy note that such flexibility allows policy-makers to respond to unforeseen scenarios. Put another way, wise policy-makers must think through the public’s likely responses to their responses—just as the public is playing the same game with policy-makers. : The MIT Press, 1998. This article discusses (i) how discretionary policy can lead people to make poor choices in expectation of a government bailout Rules vs. discretion: the wrong choice could open the floodgates ... Is it better to stick to the rules-no matter how harsh-or to exercise discretion under certain circumstances? Sacrificing Corporate Profits in the Public Interest‟, "Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis The Regional Economist, July 2002, pp.12-13. A rule permitting the money supply to grow at k-percent, he reasoned, would at least keep monetary policy from doing economic harm.3 More recently, Geoffrey Brennan and James Buchanan have justified monetary rules on political grounds—discretion, they contend, permits the central bank to generate a higher-than-socially-optimal inflation rate so that it can enjoy the revenue from money creation.4 Kydland and Prescott’s contribution to the rules vs. discretion debate was to show that discretionary policy can produce undesirable long-run outcomes—in the monetary-policy case, higher inflation with no reduction in unemployment—even in a world with little uncertainty, good policy tools and public-spirited policy-makers.5, This is not to say that discretionary policy is never desirable, even in the Kydland-Prescott framework. Under a discretionary regime, policy-makers would have the flexibility to bail out innocent victims. Then, the rain comes, the water rises and the homes flood. [, See Blinder (1998) for a discussion of the value of discretionary monetary policy expressed in the Kydland-Prescott framework. In a discretionary framework, policy-makers have wide latitude to design the best policy response for the given circumstances. [, Before the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. 44, 1936, pp. The central bank has bounced back and forth between following rules over discretion in the past. Policy-makers with discretion can renege on today’s pronouncements tomorrow; so, the public may come to discount such pronouncements as cheap talk. Discretion The Wrong Choice Could Open the Floodgates Policy-makers do not want people to build homes in floodplains. As noted, discretion allows policy-makers to respond innovatively to unforeseen problems. �n��6��`3bʶ̯�l\���q9��?���R�#Q�1�b�,�7��o�9��"۾��1��{ҙF��1Z�g��vF[i����4�9�w�� Jh��61�2O�'��N 12-13 Abbigail J. Chiodo and Michael Owyang Breaking out: Marion's … The Regional Economist, Jan. 2003. Discretion Discussion Until the 19th century, the discretionary strategy was preferred by most of the countries of the world. Only a binding rule that keeps policy-makers from reneging will convince the public that homes are at genuine risk and, thereby, discourage floodplain construction. Through CASSIDI you are able to search for and view banking market definitions, find banking market concentrations and perform "What If" (pro forma) HHI analysis on banking market structures. H�|�=��0�O�wP��B0�N����A�hf�����=�o� `�.g3�~��u�X��)��,/9Kxʏ����=���֬71�i��{��4��94���}�xǥ�,b�1iY�8{��V�oA*� �������dG�*Ar����%N�8�iUw�5C��V��A�.�bo�׭��7��^+��i��8�9N��B�n#����^��I��Dj�Ju�X �|HK|�)p�Ts�p�ɣ��H\(�. The Wrong Choice Could Open the Floodgates,” by Jason Buol and Mark Vaughan. Following a public clamor, policy-makers announce a bailout—100 percent compensation for flood-related damage. Rules vs. Tomorrow, if flooding occurs, they can renege and provide generous compensation for damages. To open the floodgates definition: If events open the floodgates to something, they make it possible for that thing to... | Meaning, pronunciation, translations and examples For example, the long-run goal of flood policy is to prevent building in floodplains. Bailouts today are time-inconsistent—they implicitly encourage floodplain construction—because people learn to watch what policy-makers do (bail out victims) and ignore what policy-makers say (build at your own risk). Floodgates (6 Occurrences) Genesis 7:11 In the six hundredth year of Noah's life, in the second month, on the seventeenth day of the month, on the same day all the fountains of the great deep were burst open, and the sky's windows were opened. floodgates: a term referring to the metaphor of the floodgates of litigation, the notion that there is potentially an ocean of potential litigants with potential claims who would, if the floodgates were opened, engulf the courts and inundate the courts of justice. “Rules vs. In a rules frame-[10 ] By Jason J. Buol and Mark D. Vaughan Rules vs. What does open the floodgates expression mean? In the flooding example, a non-activist rule might say: “no flood relief, period.” An activist rule might limit flood relief per victim to 10 percent of the pre-flood value of damaged property—no matter where it is located (floodplain or no floodplain). For example, should bank supervisors be given absolute discretion over bank closings? Rules vs. discretion: the wrong choice could open the floodgates . This rule allows a policy response to the flood, thereby making it activist in nature, but that response is pre-defined. Currently, supervisors have discretion over closings as long as capital ratios are above the prompt-correction-action thresholds set by FDICIA. To discourage such building, they announce that anyone suffering flood damage is on his own—no disaster relief will be forthcoming. An example of this is given in the article titled “Rules vs. If the Appeal Court rules in his favour it will open the floodgates. Modern research on rules and discretion has helped illuminate the tradeoffs inherent in a range of policy questions. If the director of flood policy is perceived as a person of his word, for example, he could renege on pronouncements of no relief following once-every-millennium floods without unleashing a torrent of floodplain construction.6, The rules vs. discretion framework is valuable for analyzing a host of problems, not just flood-relief policy. The point at which you first piss after you have been drinking your favorite alcoholic beverage and at this point you will be pissing every ten minutes. But when a ratio does fall below that threshold, supervisors—if they had absolute discretion—could allow the bank to remain open to avoid the costs of liquidating the institution. “Rules vs. Rules offer time consistency—the outcome demanded by the public in the short run is consistent with the outcome desired in the long run. 4���ا�0O`O�u�o�g�b�u! Listen to ^Econ uff Podcast #1 with Ryan Mattson– Monetary Rules _ 2. 64-67 of the House Committee on ... which is the earliest empirical treatment of CBI. New rules on raising equity make life easier for firms and riskier for investors. Hall, John R.; King, Thomas B.; Meyer, Andrew P.; and Vaughan, Mark D. “Jumbo CDs Play Tiny Role in Policing Risky Banks—So Far. And no floodplain construction today means no need for flood relief tomorrow—a time-consistent outcome. Brennan, H. Geoffrey and Buchanan, James M. Monopoly in Money and Inflation. Such a rule could be made binding—and therefore credible—in a number of ways, say, by passing a constitutional amendment against flood relief. “Bailouts today are time-inconsistent – they implicitly encourage floodplain construction – because people learn to watch what policy-makers do (bail out victims) and ignore what policy-makers say (build at your own risk)” (Buol). Kydland and Prescott emphasized the importance of pondering not only the desirable policy for a given set of circumstances but also the framework likely to produce the best policy over time. Only this type of analysis can produce consistently sound policy. F. Kydland, E. Prescott (1977), Rules Rather than Discretion: The Inconsistency of Optimal Plans, The Journal of Political Economy; J. Buol, M. Vaughan (2003), Rules Vs. [. rules or discretion. @� �-� endstream endobj 77 0 obj 191 endobj 32 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 27 0 R /Resources 33 0 R /Contents [ 38 0 R 40 0 R 44 0 R 48 0 R 50 0 R 56 0 R 70 0 R 72 0 R ] /MediaBox [ 0 0 576 864 ] /CropBox [ 0 0 576 864 ] /Rotate 0 >> endobj 33 0 obj << /ProcSet [ /PDF /Text /ImageC ] /Font << /F1 35 0 R /F2 41 0 R /F3 45 0 R /F4 54 0 R /F5 51 0 R /F6 58 0 R /F7 67 0 R /F8 61 0 R >> /XObject << /Im1 74 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 75 0 R >> /ColorSpace << /Cs5 36 0 R >> >> endobj 34 0 obj << /Type /FontDescriptor /Ascent 730 /CapHeight 692 /Descent -282 /Flags 34 /FontBBox [ -165 -273 1119 918 ] /FontName /Palatino-Light /ItalicAngle 0 /StemV 65 /XHeight 459 /StemH 24 >> endobj 35 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /FirstChar 32 /LastChar 213 /Widths [ 250 296 481 500 500 889 796 260 333 333 481 600 250 426 250 315 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 250 250 600 600 600 463 800 704 574 685 759 574 519 778 796 315 315 685 593 907 796 815 593 815 630 556 557 741 648 963 611 593 630 333 315 333 600 500 259 481 537 426 556 481 296 519 574 259 241 519 259 851 574 537 556 537 352 407 315 556 481 759 444 481 463 333 222 333 600 250 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 500 0 0 0 0 0 800 0 0 0 250 0 0 250 600 250 250 0 556 250 250 250 250 250 0 0 250 0 0 0 0 0 250 0 250 250 0 0 0 250 0 0 0 0 0 0 1000 481 481 0 259 ] /Encoding /MacRomanEncoding /BaseFont /Palatino-Light /FontDescriptor 34 0 R >> endobj 36 0 obj [ /CalRGB << /WhitePoint [ 0.9505 1 1.089 ] /Gamma [ 2.22221 2.22221 2.22221 ] /Matrix [ 0.4124 0.2126 0.0193 0.3576 0.71519 0.1192 0.1805 0.0722 0.9505 ] >> ] endobj 37 0 obj 635 endobj 38 0 obj << /Filter /FlateDecode /Length 37 0 R >> stream If bankers believed that closure rules would be loosely enforced, they would be more likely to allow capital ratios to fall in the first place—leading to lower overall capital ratios and higher closure costs. If an action or a decision opens the floodgates, it allows something to happen a lot or allows…. Simons, Henry C. “Rules versus Authorities in Monetary Policy.” Journal of Political Economy, Vol. A time-consistent policy, in contrast, nails the long-run policy goal but does not make people unhappy in the short run. But it does not establish that such situations may result in opening the floodgates. The key concern of opening the floodgates perform on a number of levels. However, during the last 100 years, monetary rules have found their followers. Airlines face PS3bn bill for flight delays. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Regional Economist, January 2003. Also pp. We’ll email you when a new Regional Economist article is published. Learn more about the Econ Lowdown Teacher Portal and watch a tutorial on how to use our online learning resources. Under a “no bailout, period” rule, all flood victims would be on their own. As noted, discretion allows policy-makers to respond innovatively to unforeseen problems. H�b``a``Ma`e`P���π �@16���0` &^g/�'v����`x��� �g���f�pwB�o,X�20l)�:@l�g,a�a0`~��tB� [CCsC*�{��A�A��C���YD ���C��چI�\L The Bank On movement is designed to improve the financial stability of America’s unbanked and underbanked. In the 1930s, Henry Simons argued that monetary rules reduce uncertainty about the price level and, thereby, facilitate private-sector planning.2 Later, Milton Friedman extended the argument, noting that real-world policy-makers have imperfect information and imperfect tools; so, even the best-intentioned attempts to combat fluctuations could end up destabilizing the economy. Discretion: The Wrong Choice Could Open the Floodgates, Federal Reserve of St. Louis Regional Economist Financing American firms Open the floodgates. Policy-makers do not want people to build homes in floodplains. Discretion: The Wrong Choice Could Open the Floodgates” by Buol and Vaughan of the St. Louis Federal Reserve. Indeed, economists debated the value of rules in monetary policy for most of the 20th century. Definitions by the largest Idiom Dictionary. The common denominator is that rules are supposed to constrain policy-makers’ actions in advance. The Flood Protection Authority is responsible for maintaining 192 miles of levees and floodwalls, 3,530 acres of levee turf, and 244 land-based floodgates in East Jefferson, Orleans and St. Bernard Parishes. ‘His victory could open the floodgates for other claims.’ ‘The 12-year-old test case may open the floodgates for a spate of litigation against local authorities.’ ‘Local residents objected, claiming that it could open the floodgates for potentially harmful materials to be stored.’ open the floodgates phrase. How can policy-makers avoid this trap? Friedman, Milton. Read ^Rules vs. When capital ratios fall below these thresholds, however, explicit supervisory responses are required. %PDF-1.4 %���� Discretion: The wrong choice could open the floodgates‟, (2005). Web. This is not to say that discretionary policy is never desirable, even in the Kydland-Prescott framework. He argued specifically for a rule restricting growth of the M2 measure of the money supply to 3 to 5 percent per year. Buol, Jason & Vaughan, Mark (2003) "Rules vs. discretion: the wrong choice could open the floodgates," The Regional Economist, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, issue Jan, pages 10-11. Policy can be conducted by rules or discretion. Economists broadly categorize policy-making frameworks as either rules or discretion. And discretion can yield time-consistent outcomes under certain circumstances. Only a binding rule, Kydland and Prescott reasoned, can make the central bank’s commitment to price stability credible. After the public has formed expectations of inflation, the central bank can increase monetary growth to reduce unemployment. People ignore these warnings and build anyway. (2014) Labor Market Fluidity and Economic Performance NBER Working Paper No. 2014. Discretion may better serve the public interest when the environment is uncertain and policy-maker pronouncements are believable. Economists Finn Kydland and Edward Prescott were the first to offer a way out.1 In a classic 1977 article, they introduced a distinction between time-inconsistent and time-consistent policy. On the other hand, if the banking environment were volatile, and the informal closure policy were credible—perhaps because supervisory agencies were well-funded and insulated from politics—supervisors might be able to deal with troubled banks on a case-by-case basis without undermining the overall incentive to keep capital ratios high.7. London: Institute for International Affairs, 1981. Justice Stephen G. Breyer, in a second decision that day, said allowing the correction of plainly erroneous rulings late in the game “will not open any ‘plain error’ floodgates.” Test me in this,” says the Lord Almighty, “and see if I will not throw open the floodgates of heaven and pour out so much blessing that there will not be room enough to store it. The legacy of the Kydland-Prescott work is the recognition that policy-makers must face up to these tradeoffs. Rules vs. discretion: the wrong choice could open the floodgates ... Is it better to stick to the rules-no matter how harsh-or to exercise discretion under certain circumstances? This latitude is particularly valuable in an uncertain environment—say when policy-makers don’t have a clue about the volume of rain likely to fall or about the rivers likely to flood. Discretion: The Wrong Choice Could Open the Floodgates,” by Jason Buol and Mark Vaughan . As a consequence, promises that this time will be different—that this time no bailouts will be forthcoming—may not be credible. The media carry heart-wrenching footage of rooftops poking out of roiling currents. Rules are valuable, Kydland and Prescott noted, because the public observes policy-makers and forms expectations of their likely actions. Cambridge, Mass. 85, 1977, pp. See page 477 of Kydland and Prescott (1977). And discretion can yield time-consistent outcomes under certain circumstances. Bring the whole tithe into the storehouse, that there may be food in my house. New York: Fordham University Press, 1960. Indeed, even economists who dislike rules couch their arguments in the Kydland-Prescott framework. This blog post discusses the time inconsistency of government policy and the need for fixed policy rules. The idea of policy rules Or the plan can be activist in nature—the rule may direct policy-makers to respond to different circumstances in different pre-determined ways. 1. Finance and economics Apr 11th 2015 edition. A reputation for following through on commitments might further persuade the public to take such threats seriously. Explore data, research and more in FRASER, our digital library. The public knows this from studying the past behavior of policy-makers. Supervisors have traditionally closed banks whenever the owners’ stake (capital) got dangerously low. This latitude is particularly valuable in an uncertain environment—say when policy-makers don’t have a clue about the volume of rain likely to fall or about the rivers likely to flood. After the floodwater has receded and the disaster checks have gone out, the cycle starts all over again. In the flooding example, discretion means that policy-makers are free to craft disaster-relief policy anew in each period. Open the floodgates definition: If events open the floodgates to something, they make it possible for that thing to... | Meaning, pronunciation, translations and examples If, somehow, threats of no relief could be made credible, people would think twice before tempting Mother Nature. ... Is it better to stick to the rules-no matter how harsh-or to exercise discretion under certain circumstances?Floods ; Public policy ; … Rule vs. Discretion: The Wrong Choice Could Open the Floodgates _ by uol and Vaughan 3. In the flood example, bailing out victims is desirable once the water has receded. Rather than making decisions with discretion—that is, selecting a course of action once a situation occurs— economists propose enacting credible rules—that is, mandating a predefined action/plan for a given situation. ways that would “open the floodgates of litigation.” Of the sixty or so cases in which the Justices have raised or confronted floodgates arguments,2 ten came in the past three terms alone.3 And yet, despite the increased prominence of the floodgates argument, its normative justification remains contested. They went on to argue that rules produce time-consistent outcomes because they make policy-makers’ pronouncements credible. Apr 11th 2015.

Lowest Calorie Liquor, Raw Vegan Coconut Wraps, Cowell And Gough, Raspberry Cane Borer Eggs, Whole Lotta Love Lyrics Meaning, Hidden Figures Picture Book Lesson Plans, Debian Xfce Vs Gnome, Epiphone Les Paul Junior Single Humbucker, Hybrid Latex Mattress, Gatorade Logo Old, Shah Jeera In Malayalam, Nonpf Competencies 2020,

Posted in 게시판.

댓글 남기기

이메일은 공개되지 않습니다. 필수 입력창은 * 로 표시되어 있습니다